Gloria died on December 27, 2025. My partner flew in from New York the day before to be by her side. She’d been in an oxygen tent at a vet near my parents’ house for two days, fighting what turned out to be her last fight.
She was my mini schnauzer, nearly 16, and she was my everything. On Christmas Day, I noticed her breathing had gone shallow. I knew. I didn’t say it out loud because I didn’t want to wreck the holiday, but I knew. So I rushed her in. Congestive heart failure, the vet said.
She never came home.
The bill came to $2,354 for the two days she was there (not including cremation and airfare). I did not have pet insurance. That’s one of my biggest regrets as a pet owner. I used to think of insurance as an add-on, but looking back at the numbers now, I realize I was gambling on a reality that no longer exists.
A new study from Healthy Paws Pet Insurance – based on a survey of 1,590 U.S. dog and cat owners – puts some cold, hard data behind what I felt in that emergency waiting room: this is getting expensive in a way most household budgets simply aren’t built for.
Routine care for a single dog or cat now averages $4,272 per year. Over a 12-year lifespan, that’s more than $50,000 per pet. For perspective, you can get a brand new Audi or even a Cadillac for that kind of cash.
And that’s before anything goes wrong.
What a Pet Emergency Actually Costs
I knew prices were climbing, but the Department of Labor data cited in the Healthy Paws study is staggering. The price of pet services, from vet care to grooming, surged 38% between January 2021 and January 2026.
If you feel like your vet bill looks more like a mortgage payment, you aren’t imagining it; veterinary care alone climbed about 43% in that same stretch.
The average Healthy Paws claim reached $392 in 2025, up 32% from 2020. Treatment for abdominal conditions has nearly doubled since then. Cancer care costs are up roughly 49%, and treatment for foreign body ingestion (your dog ate something it shouldn’t have) is up about 45%.
Our dog Margot, a Jack Russell Bull Terrier mix, started having seizures late in her life. The vet suspected liver disease or a brain tumor. Because she was nearly 17 and we were uninsured, we made the call not to pursue diagnostics that wouldn’t change the outcome. We just wanted her comfortable.
She passed at home on June 22, 2023. I don’t regret the decision we made. I do regret that money was even part of the conversation.
Our other dog, Mingo, a 13-year-old long-haired chihuahua, had all of his teeth removed a couple of years ago. Small breeds like chihuahuas are prone to bad teeth, and he’d been in pain we hadn’t fully recognized. The improvement afterward was immediate. He also had seizures when he was younger, which isn’t uncommon in small dogs with low blood sugar. We manage it with a high-calorie nutritional paste every morning instead of medication.
That paste, Tomlyn Nutri-Cal high-calorie paste, used to cost $7 to $9 a tube. It runs $16 now. The four-pack we buy? Up from around $41 before 2023 to nearly $69 today. The Science Diet senior formula we fed all of our dogs for years went from $31 per bag to $61 on Amazon. Same bag. Same brand.
None of those numbers is dramatic on its own, but together, they add up to a breaking point.
The Numbers Behind the Sticker Shock
The Healthy Paws study found that I’m not alone in feeling the squeeze. About 36% of pet owners are now spending $100 or more per month just on food and treats. Another 29% are spending at least that much on monthly vet care.
If a pet has a chronic condition, the situation gets much more serious.
About a quarter of those owners reported spending between $5,000 and $10,000 on pet-related costs in the past year. More than half, at 58%, said those expenses cause them real financial stress.
When an unexpected bill hits, 38% of people say they’d have to put it on a credit card, while 20% would have to drain their entire savings. I know exactly what that panic feels like.
When Does Pet Insurance Actually Pay Off?
On paper, this looks like a math problem. In the waiting room, it’s all emotional.
The average monthly premium runs about $62 for dogs and $32 for cats. It’s a real monthly expense, no question. But set it against a $3,000 emergency or a $7,000 surgery and the math shifts fast.
Among pet owners who have insurance, 75% told Healthy Paws their pet insurance has significantly reduced their out-of-pocket stress.
“Peace of mind” feels like an undersell. When Gloria was in that oxygen tube, the only question that should have mattered was whether she could get strong enough to come home. Instead, cost was part of the mental math. That’s a terrible place to be when you’re watching your dog struggle to breathe.
Two friends recently adopted a rescue Chihuahua and immediately signed up for pet insurance through Healthy Paws. They’re completely sold on it. Whenever a new dog picks us (I say it that way because dogs tend to arrive on their own schedule), pet insurance is the first call I’m making. Day one.
The Mistake Most Pet Owners Make
They wait.
They figure they’ll get insurance once something starts going wrong. But that’s exactly how you end up unprotected. Pre-existing conditions are excluded from coverage across most plans, which means the window to enroll is before anything is diagnosed.
Young, healthy dogs are the ideal candidates. The monthly cost is lower and you’re building a safety net before a diagnosis closes the door on you.
I waited too long with Gloria. And with Margot. I won’t do that again.
Every day I think about her. She wasn’t a particularly cuddly dog. That wasn’t really her style. But she had a way of sitting just close enough, right next to you, that said everything. She was my best girl. She deserved better financial planning from me.
Get the insurance on day one, so whatever comes next, you don’t have to wait.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does pet insurance actually save you money?
For most pet owners, yes, especially when a major emergency hits. According to a 2026 Healthy Paws study, 75% of insured pet owners say their plan has significantly reduced their out-of-pocket vet costs. Whether it pays off over a lifetime depends on your pet’s health history, but a single serious emergency can easily cost more than a full year of premiums.
What does pet insurance typically not cover?
Most standard policies exclude pre-existing conditions, routine wellness care (annual exams, vaccines), elective procedures and breeding-related costs. Some providers offer optional wellness add-ons for an extra monthly fee. Always read the policy carefully before enrolling.
When is the best time to get pet insurance?
Day one. The younger and healthier the animal, the lower the premium, and any condition that develops before enrollment is typically excluded as pre-existing. Waiting until something is wrong almost always means you’re too late to cover it.
How much does pet insurance cost per month?
Average premiums run about $62 per month for dogs and $32 for cats, according to NAPHIA data. Your actual cost depends on your pet’s age, breed, location and the deductible and reimbursement level you choose.
What is “economic euthanasia,” and how common is it?
Economic euthanasia refers to the situation where a pet is put down not because of a medical prognosis, but because the owner cannot afford to treat it. It’s more common than most people realize, and it’s one of the primary reasons veterinarians and financial planners increasingly recommend pet insurance as a baseline part of responsible pet ownership.
For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.
Read the full article here
