Joe Amabile and Serena Pitt want Jason Tartick to follow in their Bachelor in Paradise footsteps.
“I think he would be great,” Serena, 27, exclusively told Us Weekly at the 2025 iHeartRadio Music Awards on Monday, March 17. “I don’t know if he would do it.” Amabile, 38, added that he “would personally love” to see Jason, 36, find love on the beaches of Mexico.
Bachelorette and Paradise alum Blake Horstmann shared a similar comment while exclusively chatting with Us at the Newport Beach Celebrity Classic earlier this month. “I don’t think he’d ever do Paradise, but I would love to see him find himself a nice, normal woman,” Horstmann, 35, shared on Sunday, March 16. “He would be fun, though.”
Jason made his Bachelor Nation debut on season 14 of The Bachelorette in 2018. Though he didn’t find love with leading lady Becca Kufrin, he began dating former Bachelorette Kaitlyn Bristowe in 2019 and popped the question in 2021. After four years of dating, the pair ended their engagement in August 2023.
“We are beyond thankful for the memories made together, and for your support of us and the boys throughout the years,” the exes wrote in a joint Instagram statement at the time. “Moving forward we will always have that level of support for each other. We don’t know what the future holds so please try to hold space for us in your hearts.”
Kaitlyn has been romantically linked to fellow Bachelor Nation star Zac Clark since January 2024, though the two have yet to confirm their relationship status. Jason, meanwhile, moved on with influencer Kat Stickler in April 2024. The pair dated for six months before ending things that October.
While Jason’s reality TV romance didn’t last, Serena and Joe have been going strong since falling in love on season 7 of Paradise in 2021. The couple tied the knot during an October 2022 courthouse ceremony before saying “I do” in front of family and friends in September 2023.
Jason isn’t the only Bachelor Nation star Serena and Joe want to see appear on Paradise.
“We think Andrew [Spencer] and Greg [Grippo] make great television. If they’re both single, I wouldn’t be mad about seeing them back in Paradise together,” Serena told Us on Monday. “And we’ve never seen Greg Grippo on Paradise, so I think maybe this is his year.” (Andrew, 30, previously appeared on the spinoff’s eighth season in 2022.)
As for whether the spouses would consider making a cameo during the show’s new episodes, Serena said, “Yeah, I think so if they asked me. I mean, it’s been a while since we’ve been down there.”
Joe noted that the pair have a “soft spot for Paradise,” adding, “If they asked, I think we would be there in a heartbeat, for sure.”
ABC has yet to announce which Bachelor Nation singles will appear on Paradise season 10 later this year. Serena and Joe, however, have some helpful words of advice for the show’s next group of romantic hopefuls.
“Don’t overthink it,” Joe stated. “Just go in there with a blank slate and try to have fun.”
Serena added, “If you’re single and you’re questioning it, it’s worth it. I mean, it worked out for us, so we’re very biased. But we definitely always encourage people to go if they’re considering it.”
With reporting by Mike Vulpo
Read the full article here
